The Influential Underwriter – Subject Matter Expert

By Keri Herlong

“The more you know, the more you are responsible for.” –Random leader from my past insurance life.

Have you ever considered yourself a “subject matter expert” – aka SME? There are dozens of articles online with differing opinions about how long it takes to become a SME. Some reference the “10,000 hour” rule – originally proposed by Malcolm Gladwell in his book Outliers. That somewhat equates to about five years of dedicated learning and experience in a field, industry, or subject, so if you have been in your industry – in your role – for at least five years, chances are you already are one.

Embrace Your Expertise

Does the thought of being considered a “subject matter expert” terrify you? When it comes to being deposed as an expert witness, being labeled an “expert” can create anxiety, but ultimately, you know what you know and should be proud of what you’ve learned and can share with others.

However, being a SME is not just about knowing everything about your subject. You must be able to communicate your knowledge in a way that is easy for others to understand, especially to those who know absolutely nothing about the subject.

The Path to Becoming a Subject Matter Expert

The path to SME starts with you understanding your subject matter. When you have worked in a role, on a project, or with a specific industry, for example, influential underwriters can’t help but become SMEs. You likely spend the majority of your day sharing your expertise with without giving it a second thought.

The next step is being intentional about sharing your expertise, which can happen through formal mentoring of someone new. For an underwriter, this could be a junior underwriter, an agent, or someone in an associated department. In addition to those who are right out of college and getting started brand new at a company, many people change industries or careers after a decade or more. They have general expertise in business but may have very little knowledge when they are taking an entry position in a new industry. By sharing what you know with others, you build their expertise while deepening your relationship.

Once you have successfully mentored an individual, the next natural step is to share your expertise with a small group and then gradually expand to larger groups. For example, maybe you give a short presentation to your direct team. Next, to your department. As you become more comfortable, you will find that others approach you to present your subject to larger audiences – inside and outside your company! When you increase the audience, you increase your influence as well as the opportunity for your own development.

Soliciting feedback is a non-negotiable step in the process. When sharing your knowledge with others early on, it is important to request feedback to ensure your message is clear. You can train all day, every day, but if the student leaves the lesson not understanding the message, or worse, thinking they understand but missed it, you may be creating a situation where they go on to teach others incorrect information. Feedback in early sessions should include a short quiz on the key points, a survey of effectiveness of your teaching or delivery style, and the clarity of the materials you use.

What are the Benefits of Being a SME?

When you become an expert, and are recognized as such, others put a higher level of trust in you and often recognize you as a leader. This helps with your career progression.

Another benefit comes through developing and supporting relationships, and growing your network. People approach you with questions because they trust you will give them the correct response. They know they can count on you. A quiet benefit of sharing your knowledge with others is this: the people you invest in tend to invest in you, too. You grow your network of experts so when you need help with a topic outside your area of expertise, you know just the right resource.

As you become comfortable with your role as a SME, a natural consequence is confidence in your personal brand reputation. As I mentioned earlier, being considered a SME might be scary at first. Once you have overcome imposter syndrome, you can be confident in your own authority and mastery of a subject and feel comfortable sharing your knowledge. The more you share, the better you get at it, the more confidence you have in your own abilities, and the more influential you will be to your peers and colleagues.

Becoming confident in your authority can open doors to other revenue streams. As a subject matter expert, you may be able to take on independent consulting work or offer your services as an expert in legal proceedings such as mediation or arbitration.

Summary

You’ve spent years learning this industry. You’ve answered questions, solved problems, and impacted others’ careers positively. That is the definition of expertise, and the most influential thing you can do with it is stop keeping it to yourself. Share what you know, teach what you’ve lived, and watch your influence grow far beyond your own corner of the industry.